Web Analytics Made Easy - Statcounter

ADVERTISEMENT

RECIPES

White Christmas Punch with Ice Cream

ADVERTISEMENT

A clear punch bowl of white Christmas punch with vanilla ice cream and a frothy sprinkled top

White Christmas punch is a creamy holiday drink made with sweetened condensed milk, lemon-lime soda, almond extract and scoops of vanilla ice cream. The soda makes it fizzy, the milk and ice cream make it frothy, and a sprinkle of red and green nonpareils on top gives the bowl a festive finish. It is meant to be mixed in a punch bowl and served right away, while the foam is still very light.

The method is simple: whisk the sweetened condensed milk with a little of the soda and the almond extract, scoop in the vanilla ice cream, then pour in the remaining lemon-lime soda and stir gently until the punch is foamy. Top it with sprinkles and ladle it into clear glass mugs.

Why You’ll Love This White Christmas Punch

There is no cooking and no long list of steps. The ingredients are few, and the punch comes together in the bowl you serve from. The ice cream melts just enough to make a creamy foam, and the almond extract gives it a clear holiday flavor without any extra syrup. A tray of clear mugs next to the punch bowl is enough for a party table.

If you want another holiday punch from the same kitchen, try this candy cane Christmas punch too.

What Is White Christmas Punch?

White Christmas punch is a creamy, fizzy party drink built on sweetened condensed milk and lemon-lime soda, then finished with vanilla ice cream. The almond extract is the flavor that makes it taste like a holiday punch instead of plain soda and ice cream. When you stir, the ice cream and soda make a pale, frothy top that looks pretty in a clear bowl and in a clear mug.

It is not a cooked custard and it is not a milkshake. The soda should still have some sparkle, and the ice cream should be scooped in so it melts slowly rather than being fully blended. Red and green sprinkles on the foam are a simple garnish and are optional, but they match the look of a Christmas table.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ingredients for White Christmas Punch with Ice Cream

  • 14 oz sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 liters lemon-lime soda, divided, well chilled
  • 2 teaspoons almond extract
  • 48 oz vanilla ice cream
  • Red and green nonpareils or sprinkles, for the top (optional)
Unlabeled ingredients for white Christmas punch: sweetened condensed milk, lemon-lime soda, almond extract, vanilla ice cream and sprinkles

Ingredient Notes

Sweetened condensed milk is thick and already sweet, so it mixes into a creamy base without any extra sugar. Lemon-lime soda should be cold and freshly opened so the punch stays fizzy. Use a plain lemon-lime soda, not a named brand, and keep the bottles chilled until you pour. Almond extract is strong, and two teaspoons is enough for a full bowl.

Vanilla ice cream should be firm enough to scoop but not rock hard. Large scoops sit in the punch and melt into the foam as guests serve themselves. Red and green sprinkles go on at the end, right on the frothy top. If you skip them, the punch will still taste the same.

How to Make White Christmas Punch with Ice Cream

  1. Chill the soda and the ice cream: keep the lemon-lime soda cold, and have the ice cream firm enough to scoop. Set out a large clear punch bowl and a ladle.
  2. Make the creamy base: pour the sweetened condensed milk into the bowl. Add about 2 cups of the lemon-lime soda and the almond extract. Whisk until the milk is smooth and fully blended with the soda.
  3. Add the ice cream: scoop the vanilla ice cream into the bowl, spacing the scoops so they sit in the creamy base.
  4. Finish with soda: pour in the remaining lemon-lime soda. Stir gently with the ladle until the punch looks creamy and the top is foamy. Do not beat it hard, or you will lose the fizz.
  5. Garnish and serve: sprinkle red and green nonpareils over the foam if you like. Ladle the white Christmas punch into clear glass mugs, adding a little foam and a bit of ice cream to each cup. Serve right away.
Ice cream scoops being added to a punch bowl of creamy lemon-lime soda punch

Tips for the Best White Christmas Punch

Cold ingredients matter. Warm soda goes flat, and ice cream that is too soft will disappear into the bowl before you can serve it. Mix the condensed milk with a small amount of soda first so it does not sit in a thick ribbon at the bottom of the bowl. Stir from the bottom, gently, once the rest of the soda goes in.

Make this punch just before guests arrive. It is at its best in the first stretch after you pour, while the foam is light and the soda still sparkles. If the bowl sits too long, you can add a little more cold soda and stir once to wake it up, but a fresh batch is better than a bowl that has gone flat.

What to Serve With White Christmas Punch

This punch is a sweet drink, so it sits well next to a cookie tray or a simple savory snack. Clear mugs show off the creamy color, and a ladle in the bowl makes it easy for people to serve themselves. Keep extra cold soda nearby if you want to refresh the bowl later in the party.

ADVERTISEMENT

For more festive drinks and sweets from the same kitchen, try this bright green holiday punch plus this peppermint Christmas float too. These Christmas candy cane cookies and these soft Christmas peppermints are easy to set out beside the bowl as well.

Variations

You can use a little less almond extract if you want a milder bowl, or add one more drop if you like a stronger flavor. The sprinkles can be left off, or you can use only red or only green. If you want a slightly thicker punch, add a few extra scoops of ice cream; if you want it lighter, use a bit more cold soda.

This recipe is written for lemon-lime soda, not a fruit juice and not a cream soda. A different soda will change both the flavor and the color. Keep the condensed milk, almond extract and vanilla ice cream as the creamy base so the punch stays white and frothy.

A clear glass mug of white Christmas punch with foam and red and green sprinkles

Storage

White Christmas punch is best served as soon as it is mixed. Leftover punch can be covered and refrigerated for a short time, but it will lose its fizz and the foam will settle. Stir in a little fresh cold lemon-lime soda before you serve it again if you have some left in the bowl. A covered container in the refrigerator keeps the leftovers in good shape for the next day. Let the food sit for a minute at room temperature before you serve it if it has been chilled. A clean knife or spoon makes each serving neater. Keep extra garnish on the side so guests can add more if they like. Plan to finish leftovers soon, while the texture is still at its best. A little extra time in the refrigerator can help the flavors settle. Serve on a simple plate or in a simple glass so the food stays the focus. Wipe the rim of the dish before you bring it to the table.

For safe handling and storage, follow the FDA guide to safe food handling plus the USDA guide to leftovers and food safety too. Keep the dairy-rich punch cold, and do not leave a bowl sitting out on a warm table for a long stretch.

ADVERTISEMENT

FAQ

Can I make white Christmas punch ahead of time?

You can whisk the sweetened condensed milk, almond extract and a little soda ahead and keep that base cold. Add the ice cream and the remaining soda just before serving, so the punch stays fizzy and the foam stays light. The finished bowl does not hold well for hours.

Will the ice cream melt too fast?

Some melting is what makes the punch creamy. Start with firm scoops and a well-chilled soda, and serve the bowl right away. If the ice cream disappears too quickly, the soda or the room may be warm; chill both the soda and the bowl first next time.

Can I use a different extract?

Almond extract is the classic flavor for this punch. Vanilla extract will make a milder, sweeter bowl, but it will not taste quite the same. If you use almond extract, measure it carefully, because a little goes a long way.

How should I store leftovers?

Cover the bowl and refrigerate it for a short time only. The fizz will fade. A splash of fresh cold lemon-lime soda and a gentle stir will help a little, but this punch is really meant to be enjoyed the day it is made.

Do I have to add sprinkles?

No. The red and green sprinkles are only a garnish for the foam. The punch will still be creamy and fizzy without them. If you use them, add them at the last minute so the colors stay on top of the foam instead of sinking.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also
Close
Back to top button