Italian House Salad with Creamy Italian Dressing

ADVERTISEMENT

Italian house salad is a crisp restaurant-style salad of iceberg lettuce, pepperoncini, Roma tomatoes, black olives, red onion, seasoned croutons and parmesan, tossed with a creamy Italian dressing you make in the same recipe. The dressing is shaken or whisked from olive oil, white wine vinegar, water, mayonnaise, sugar, garlic, lemon juice and Italian seasoning, then chilled before you toss the bowl.
The method is simple. Shake the dressing in a jar, or whisk it in a bowl, until it looks creamy and even, then chill it so the flavors settle. Build the salad in a large bowl, toss it with enough dressing to coat, and add the croutons and parmesan at the end so the croutons stay crisp. Serve it at once, with extra dressing on the side.
Why You’ll Love This Italian House Salad
It gives you the salad and the dressing in one place, with a short list of familiar ingredients. The lettuce stays crunchy, the tomatoes and olives add color, and the creamy dressing clings without feeling heavy. It is an easy side for a weeknight pasta night or a holiday table.
The dressing can be made ahead and kept in the refrigerator, which is helpful when you are cooking a larger meal. The salad itself comes together in minutes once the lettuce is dry and the vegetables are cut.
What Is Italian House Salad?
Italian house salad is a green salad built on iceberg lettuce and finished with a creamy Italian dressing. The bowl usually includes pepperoncini, sliced Roma tomatoes, black olives, thin red onion, seasoned croutons and a little parmesan. The dressing gets its body from mayonnaise mixed with olive oil and white wine vinegar, then garlic, lemon juice, sugar and Italian seasoning.
It is a green salad, not a pasta salad. If you want a pasta salad for the same table, see Christmas tortellini salad or million-dollar spaghetti salad. For a warm bowl to serve beside this Italian house salad, try pasta e fagioli soup or minestrone soup. A slice of simple focaccia bread is a natural partner for mopping up extra dressing.
ADVERTISEMENT
Ingredients for Italian House Salad
For the salad:
- 6 cups iceberg lettuce
- 6 pepperoncini peppers
- 4 Roma tomatoes
- 1 cup black olives
- 1 cup thinly sliced red onion
- 1 cup seasoned croutons
- 1/4 cup parmesan cheese
For the creamy Italian dressing:
- 2/3 cup olive oil
- 1/3 cup white wine vinegar
- 3 tablespoons water
- 2 tablespoons mayonnaise
- 1 tablespoon sugar
- 2 teaspoons fresh minced garlic
- 2 teaspoons lemon juice
- 1 1/2 teaspoons Italian seasoning
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/4 teaspoon red pepper flakes

Ingredient Notes
Iceberg lettuce is the crunch of this salad. Six cups is a packed, chopped or torn measure, dried well so the dressing clings. Roma tomatoes hold their shape when sliced; cut them into rounds or wedges. Pepperoncini add a mild pickle heat; drain them well. Black olives and thin red onion give the bowl its classic look. If the onion tastes sharp, soak the slices in cold water for 10 minutes and pat them dry.
Seasoned croutons go on at the end so they stay crisp. Parmesan can be shredded or shaved; a quarter cup is enough to finish the bowl without burying the vegetables.
The dressing starts with olive oil, white wine vinegar and a little water, then mayonnaise to make it creamy. Sugar balances the vinegar. Fresh minced garlic and lemon juice keep the flavor bright, and Italian seasoning, kosher salt, black pepper and red pepper flakes season the jar. Shake or whisk until the mayonnaise disappears into a smooth, pourable dressing.
ADVERTISEMENT
How to Make Italian House Salad
Add the olive oil, white wine vinegar, water, mayonnaise, sugar, minced garlic, lemon juice, Italian seasoning, kosher salt, black pepper and red pepper flakes to a jar with a tight lid. Seal the jar and shake until the dressing is creamy and even, with no streaks of mayonnaise left. You can also whisk the same ingredients in a bowl. Chill the dressing for at least 30 minutes, or up to a day, so the flavors blend.
Wash the iceberg lettuce and dry it thoroughly, then chop or tear it into bite-size pieces and place it in a large bowl. Slice the Roma tomatoes into rounds or wedges. Drain the pepperoncini and the black olives. Slice the red onion thinly. Add the tomatoes, pepperoncini, olives and onion to the lettuce.
Just before serving, pour on enough chilled creamy Italian dressing to coat the salad, then toss gently. Add the seasoned croutons and the parmesan and toss once more. Serve the Italian house salad at once, with any remaining dressing on the side.

Tips for the Best Italian House Salad
Dry the lettuce well. Water left on the leaves thins the dressing and makes the salad watery. A salad spinner helps, or use a clean towel.
Chill the dressing before you toss. The short rest in the refrigerator lets the garlic and Italian seasoning bloom, and the dressing thickens slightly.
ADVERTISEMENT
Toss the salad at the last minute, and add the croutons last. A dressed bowl that sits too long wilts, and early croutons turn soft. For a crowd, set extra dressing and croutons on the table.
Taste the dressing after it chills. You can add a pinch more salt or a little more vinegar, but start with the amounts written here.
What to Serve With Italian House Salad
This Italian house salad is a side, not a pasta dish, so it sits well next to soup or a baked pasta. Serve it with pasta e fagioli soup or minestrone soup, or put it on the table with simple focaccia bread. It also works as the green salad on a holiday spread, beside a richer pasta salad.
Variations
You can add sliced cucumber, or use fewer pepperoncini for a milder bowl. A mix of iceberg and romaine still gives you crunch if you want a deeper green color. If you prefer a lighter dressing, use a little less mayonnaise and shake the jar again before serving. Leave the red pepper flakes out if you are cooking for anyone who does not want heat.

Storage
Store leftover creamy Italian dressing in a sealed jar in the refrigerator for up to 1 week. Shake it again before you use it, because it can separate as it sits. Do not leave the jar at room temperature for more than 2 hours, since the dressing contains mayonnaise.
ADVERTISEMENT
A fully tossed Italian house salad is best eaten right away. If you need to work ahead, keep the dry salad, the croutons and the dressing separate, then toss just before serving. Leftover dressed salad can be refrigerated for a short time, but the lettuce will soften and the croutons will not stay crisp. For leftover timing, see the USDA leftovers and food safety page. Wash the lettuce and tomatoes before you cut them; the FDA guidance on selecting and serving produce safely is a useful reminder for salad prep.
FAQ
Can I make the creamy Italian dressing ahead?
Yes. The dressing is even better after it chills. Shake or whisk it, then refrigerate it for at least 30 minutes, or up to 1 week in a sealed jar. Shake it again before you toss the salad, because the oil and vinegar can separate.
When should I add the croutons?
Add the seasoned croutons at the end, just after you toss the salad with dressing, and serve right away. If they go in too early, they soak up dressing and lose their crunch. For a party, you can pass extra croutons at the table.
Can I use a lettuce other than iceberg?
Iceberg is the classic crunch for this Italian house salad, and it holds up under a creamy dressing. Romaine or a mix of iceberg and romaine will work if you want a deeper green color. Softer lettuces wilt faster once they are dressed, so toss those at the last minute and serve at once.
How long does leftover dressing keep?
Keep leftover creamy Italian dressing in a sealed jar in the refrigerator for up to 1 week, and shake it before each use. Because it contains mayonnaise, do not leave it out for more than 2 hours. If it smells off, throw it away.
Can I make Italian house salad ahead of a meal?
You can wash and dry the lettuce, cut the vegetables, and make the dressing several hours ahead. Keep everything separate, and wait to toss the salad, croutons and parmesan until you are ready to serve. A fully dressed bowl does not hold well, because the lettuce wilts.
Italian house salad is a crisp, familiar bowl with a creamy Italian dressing you can shake in a jar and keep on hand. Chill the dressing, keep the lettuce dry, toss at the last minute, and finish with croutons and parmesan. Serve it beside soup or focaccia, and bring the extra dressing to the table with you.




